Fresh Italian Cookies
Monroeville , PA
Made-From-Scratch Bakery
90+ Year Old Recipes
Fresh, Local Ingredients
Indulge in Our Irresistible Cookies Today!
Looking for a sweet treat that reminds you of grandma's kitchen? Moio's Italian Pastry Shop has been baking delicious cookies since 1935. Our time-tested recipes, passed down for over 90 years, create treats that will delight your taste buds. We use fresh, local ingredients to make our cookies from scratch, ensuring each one is perfect.
Contact us to order and enjoy a taste of our family tradition.
A Cookie for Every Occasion
Our Italian cookie selections are sold by the pound. You'll get about 2 dozen cookies in our 1-pound assortment. We normally recommend 1 to 2 pounds for 10 people. Moio's Italian Pastry Shop recommends the full assortment for large gatherings, but you can certainly pick and choose what you like.
Our Italian selection will stay fresh for up to two weeks if kept refrigerated. If you double wrap them, they'll stay fresh for up to three months in the freezer.
Want to try our delicious cookies?
Contact us to learn about our tasty options.
Butterball
A butter based cookie with walnuts mixed in the dough. Also sometimes called a Mexican tea cookie or Italian wedding cookie.
Butternut
A butter cookie decorated with hazelnuts.
Butter Cherry
A butter cookie decorated with a cherry half.
Butter Dipped
A butter cookie dipped in chocolate ganache and sprinkles
Fruit Filled
Our take on a fig newton. A soft chewy dough filled with apples, dates, and raisins and topped with hazelnuts
Raspberry Filled
Our delicious raspberry buttercream sandwiched between two butter cookies.
Chocolate Fudge Filled
Chocolate fudge icing sandwiched between two butter cookies.
Jelly Filled
A light lemon dough cookie with raspberry jelly sandwiched between and topped with hazelnuts
Heart Cut
A lightly flavored lemon cut dough with sprinkles
Chocolate Crescent
A chocolate flavored cut dough in a crescent shaped and topped with hazelnuts
Chocolate Button
A chocolate cut cookie dough with a chocolate fudge icing and topped with sprinkles
Iced Button
A lemon cut cookie with fondant icing and topped with sprinkles
Pignoli
Pure almond paste cookie and rolled in pine nuts
Sesame
A light lemon flavored short dough coated in sesame seeds
Thumbprint Cookie
A walnut based dough with a fondant icing center.
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Our delicious chocolate chip cookies. Not chewy but not hard. The perfect snap and melt in your mouth.
Plain Macaroon
A soft and chewy cookie made from pure almond paste
Fancy Macaroon
A pure almond paste cookie decorated to look like a strawberry and topped with a cherry
Coconut Macaroon
A classic coconut macaroon topped with a cherry
Chocolate Coconut Macaroon
A traditional coconut macaroon topped in milk chocolate
Anise Biscotti
An Italian classic flavored with Anise seeds
Almond Biscotti
An Italian classic biscotti with slivered almonds
Chocolate Biscotti
An Italian classic flavored with chocolate and slivered almonds
Vanilla Biscotti
An Italian classic flavored with vanilla and pieces of cherries
Chocolate Dipped Biscotti
Our classic almond flavored biscotti covered in a delicious milk chocolate
Fruit Biscotti
A softer cake-like biscotti with an assortment of nuts and fruits inside.
Golden Nut Bar
A cookie base layered with caramel, cherries, and pecans on top.
Gingerbread
A classic honey gingerbread cookie.
View Our Full Cookie Menu
Menu
Italian Cookies
Menu
Cookies
Almond
Anise
Chocolate
Chocolate-Dipped
Vanilla
Menu
Italian Cookie Trays and Boxes
About 6 dozen
About 8 dozen
About 10 dozen
About 2 dozen
About 4 dozen
Reviews
Authentic Italian Pastries
Experience the taste of 90+ years of made-from-scratch recipes crafted with fresh, local ingredients. Every bite is a celebration of heritage and quality.
Start your order today


































