Relish Our Assorted Cookies

All Products Baked From Scratch Using Papa's Original Recipes and the Finest Ingredients

Over 80 Years of Experience

Old-Fashioned Italian Recipes

Freshest Ingredients Used

Enjoy Our Selection of Fresh Italian Cookies

Our Italian cookie selections are sold by the pound. You'll get about 2 dozen cookies in our 1-pound assortment. We normally recommend 1 to 2 pounds for 10 people. Moio's Italian Pastry Shop recommends the full assortment for large gatherings, but you can certainly pick and choose what you like. Of course, this will affect the price.

Our Italian selection will stay fresh for up to two weeks if kept refrigerated. If you double wrap them, they'll stay fresh for up to three months in the freezer.

Our Italian Cookie Trays

Includes our full assortment of Italian cookies.

3-pound tray - about 6 dozen - $70.00
5-pound tray - about 10 dozen - $110.00
Small box - about 2 dozen - $30.00
Large box - about 4 dozen - $45.00

Prices are subject to change!

Useful tip: if you're serving cookies at a wedding or big party, you may want to put them out after dinner with coffee. People will be fuller at that time and won't need as many.

Our Fancy Italian Cookie Assortment

Pignoli
Fancy macaroon
Plain macaroon
Coconut macaroon
Chocolate-covered coconut
Fruit filled
Golden nut bar
Jelly filled
Thumbprint
Butterball
Butter cherry
Butternut
Chocolate crescent
Lemon cut
Sesame
Chocolate filled
Raspberry filled
Fruit biscotti
Heart cut

Try Our Other Cookies

Chocolate chip
Gingerbread
Iced sugar
Sugar
Chocolate-dipped biscotti
Anise biscotti
Vanilla biscotti
Almond biscotti
Chocolate biscotti